Gi or No-Gi for Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu?

Traditional BJJ Grappling or Combat Submission Wrestling?

9 Comments
Join the Conversation
No-gi Brazilian jiu-jitsu: sparring in half guard - C. Bueno
No-gi Brazilian jiu-jitsu: sparring in half guard - C. Bueno
Whether to train BJJ grappling or no-gi submission wrestling is one of the grappling world's biggest debates. What are the advantages and disadvantages of each system?

What is a Brazilian Jiu Jitsu Gi?

A Brazilian jiu jitsu gi is the kimono uniform worn in traditional BJJ grappling. Similar to a judo gi, a Brazilian jiu-jitsu gi is made of heavy-weave fabric and designed to stand up to the rigorous pulling, lifting, and throwing actions of martial arts, BJJ, grappling, and submission techniques.

BJJ Grappling vs. Submission Wrestling: Major Differences

The difference between BJJ grappling and no-gi submission grappling is in the grips. In the stand-up game, the grips provided by the Brazilian jiu jitsu gi allow for many judo-style throwing and submission techniques, while no-gi submission wrestling takedowns resemble those of Greco-roman and freestyle wrestling. Grips also come into play on the ground. Where the BJJ grappling ground game is slow, measured, and technical, no-gi combat submission wrestling moves tend to be more fluid and fast-paced.

Advantages of Traditional BJJ Grappling: Developing a More Technical Game

Training with the Brazilian jiu jitsu gi appeals to BJJ purists and those who have a background in judo. Students who focus on BJJ grappling will learn the intricacies of Brazilian jiu-jitsu, including an array of grips, submission techniques, throws, holds, etc. that don’t exist in no-gi combat submission wrestling. Also, because they’ve learned to attribute greater importance to every step and grip, BJJ grappling tends to encourage a tighter and more technical overall game.

Advantages of Submission Grappling: Faster Reactions

No-gi submission grappling is very popular in North America, largely because of the wrestling tradition and the growing popularity of mixed martial arts. Also, the Abu Dhabi Combat Club tournament, one of the world’s premier submission grappling events, is exclusively no-gi. Submission wrestling’s lack of secure grips means that the action is fast-paced, positions are continually changing, and submission techniques can be hard to finish. These factors force no-gi submission grapplers to develop quick reactions and to constantly think a few extra steps ahead.

Traditional BJJ Grappling Better for Beginners

Beginners are encouraged to train in traditional BJJ grappling because the transition from Brazilian jiu jitsu to combat submission wrestling is generally easier than the reverse. Taking off the Brazilian jiu jitsu gi will make a BJJ grappler feel faster, more fluid, and more able to escape submission techniques and hold-downs. Conversely, a no-gi submission grappler who puts on a Brazilian jiu jitsu gi will feel slow and ponderous… as if they’ve been dropped into molasses.

BJJ Grappling for Self Defense

An important difference between BJJ grappling and no-gi combat submission wrestling is that the Brazilian jiu jitsu gi is more applicable to self-defense training. There are many ways to use a person’s clothing against them and most of the hold-downs, throws, and submission techniques that come into play in BJJ grappling work equally well on an opponent who is wearing regular street clothes. Students who only train in no-gi combat submission wrestling won’t be familiar with these important details and may be less adept at defending themselves while fully clothed.

Submission Grappling for Mixed Martial Arts

Since the sport of mixed martial arts is almost exclusively no-gi, fighters tend to focus on submission grappling to keep themselves tuned to the slippery and fast-paced world of MMA. That said, many top MMA fighters train mostly in BJJ grappling to hone their techniques and keep their game tight.

Train Both BJJ Grappling and Submission Wrestling

To get the best of both worlds, many Brazilian jiu-jitsu students split their training between BJJ grappling and no-gi submission wrestling. Most prefer one or the other but will train in both methods to round out their game and achieve a better overall understanding of the world of grappling.

Jeff Chan of Apostrophe Writing Services, Jeff Chan

Jeff Chan - Creative writer, business copywriter, BJJ / judo addict at JiuJitsuVortex.com, lifelong skateboarder, nature lover, and health food ...

rss
Advertisement
Leave a comment

NOTE: Because you are not a Suite101 member, your comment will be moderated before it is viewable.
Submit
What is 2+3?

Comments

Jun 27, 2009 2:24 PM
Guest :
"gi grapplers tend to develop a tighter and more technical overall game"

I would have to say that it is still too early to make this statement. No-gi grappling is an emerging sport. There hasn't been enough time to make a statement like the one above.

As more and more people begin training exclusively no-gi and it continues to advance then we will be able to see if the statement above is true.

http://www.No-Gi-Grappling.com
Jun 27, 2009 4:07 PM
Jeff Chan :
No-gi grappling has actually been around for quite a long time. Catch wrestlers like Frank Gotch and Martin "Farmer" Burns weren't wearing gis while they were submitting opponents in the late 1800s. And they weren't the first.

The 1914 match between American catch wrestler Ad Santel and 5th-degree judo black belt Tokugoro Ito was an early gi vs. no-gi showdown.

Nice site, by the way. It looks like there's enough on there to keep me busy for years.
Jan 14, 2010 3:33 PM
Guest :
Good heads up all around. Restates much of what i've learned in my little bit of BJJ training. Good additions from Jeff Chan as well. I Train under a Ceasar Gracie Brown Belt(also a 7th dan TaeKwonDo, and black belt in DanZanRyu JJ) and gi's are optional. It is incouraged to practice both styles for most of the same reasons mentioned here. Thank you.
Jan 30, 2010 3:44 AM
Guest :
"Nice site, by the way. It looks like there's enough on there to keep me busy for years."

Thanks Jeff, stop by as often as you like. Feel free to submit a technique video, product review or article anytime.
May 13, 2010 9:22 PM
Guest :
No Gi goes back as early as Alexander the Great with his development of Pancration. So to say that it is too early is wrong.

With the advancements like Eddie Bravos 10th Planet System the "technical gap" is getting smaller, but its pretty hard to argue against the fact that praticing in a gi developes a tight technical game.
Dec 4, 2010 1:27 PM
Guest :
umm actually no-gi is waaaay better for self defense. with the gi ur so dependent on the gi so the only way BJJ would be applicable is if your assailant is wearing a jacket or hoodie. what if he is wearing a tee shirt? but i suppose it depends on were u live.. i guess haha
Feb 23, 2011 10:41 AM
Guest :
I think that you are incorrect when you say that grapplers wouldn't do as well in a defence situation than traditional BJJ practisioners. When in a defence situation you will likely not be wearing long sleved apparal and also your attcker also may not. This complicates some of the moves, where in no-gi grappling you train without sleves and they won't matter to quickly and efficiently nullify the dangerous situation.
May 13, 2011 5:39 AM
Guest :
I started out as a no-gi grappler, and totally bought into the gospel according to no-gi (as preached most fervently at the time by Eddie Bravo...). Now, after two years of gi training as well (I still do both), I have come to prefer it. Part of this is purely personal - I weigh 65-67kg but most people at my gym are 80kg and above, right up to 100 and more. WIth the gi I have more grips and more leverage and this evens things out a bit when rolling with much bigger guys. Part of it is the technical aspect; I prefer the slightly slower technical game to the fast paced scramble that no gi can sometimes be.

I honestly believe that everyone who wants to improve their game should train both though. I have no doubt that my no-gi game has improved thanks to training with the gi, and vice versa. You just find yourself thinking differently, which forces you to up your game. As for self defence, no-gi probably has the edge; you can't guarantee what your assailant will be wearing, so you have to assume that it won't be something you can use. (Having said that, if they are wearing a jacket with lapels then they're going to get one hell of a shock when they get collar choked ;) )

The only time this (hopefully friendly) rivalry annoys me is when no-gi grapplers point out - and they often seem to - that a no-gi fighter will always beat an equivalent gi fighter in a no-gi fight, which is simply self-evident. It's like saying a boxer will always beat a wrestler in a boxing match.
Jun 23, 2011 12:49 PM
Guest :
the statement that one a nogi grappler will always beat a gi grappler in a nogi comp is not true. ADCC comps are predominantly won by gi grapplers. My coach, Lucas Lepri, won a world championship no gi title with very little training without the gi. Eddie Bravo schools produce far less nogi champions than Alliance or Lloyd Irvin does.
9 Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement